The Big Question Which Is Better Carpet or Hardwood Flooring

Hardwood and carpet are the two most popular flooring options, not just in Indiana but worldwide. Whether you are building a new home or remodeling the existing one, you may eventually need to decide between carpet and hardwood flooring for a room or any other space. If you are not sure about what material to pick between the two, keep reading this post.

Here, we will try to give you a brief yet complete comparative overview of carpet vs. hardwood flooring.


If you are short on budget, carpets will be a better option. On average, you can get carpet flooring at $3 per square foot compared to hardwood’s average of $8 per square foot.

Verdict: Carpet


Installation of carpet is exceedingly easier and less time-consuming than hardwood floors. But still, DIY carpet installation is not recommended because a single miscalculation can mess up the entire task.

Verdict: Carpet


Personal preference is what influences homeowners when considering the visual profile of carpet or hardwood. Most homeowners love hardwood for its clean, stylish, and elegant appearance that complements all sorts of interior decors. On the other hand, some people like carpets for the colors and designs.

Verdict: Tie

Cleaning and Maintenance

If you are using top-quality hardwood material for your floors, you don’t need to worry about their maintenance. They don’t get chipped or cracked in normal circumstances. Also, they are easy to clean. All you need is a wet mop to take care of all the dirt, stains, and other messes on the hardwood floor.

Carpet cleaning and maintenance, on the other hand, need more diligence. You will need a top-quality vacuum cleaner to ensure good carpet cleaning. It is also harder to clean carpets for stains and spills. Sometimes you even need professional cleaners to tackle stubborn stains.

Verdict: Hardwood

Value Addition

Installation of hardwood flooring increases the value of your property on real estate listings. No such thing happens with carpet installation.

Verdict: Hardwood


Hardwood justifies its higher per square foot price with its durability. A top-tier hardwood installed by seasoned contractors can last as long as the building itself, compared to a carpet’s operating life, which is no longer than 15 years irrespective of how top-quality it is.

Verdict: Hardwood

Allergies and Ventilation

Carpets trap pollen and dust in their strands that can affect air quality in the given space. It doesn’t happen with hardwood floors, making them a good option for people susceptible to respiratory allergies.

Verdict: Hardwood

Comfort Quotient

Carpets with high piles ensure soft and warm underfoot. The thread-based mesh of the carpet also absorbs the walking sound. Hardwood floors get quite cold in winters without effective heating. Also, they can produce loud noises and thuds upon walking.

Verdict: Carpet

We hope that the above comparative overview helps you pick the best option among the two in line with your particular flooring requirements and budget.

Whether you want carpet or hardwood flooring installation in Fort Wayne, Indiana, F & M Tile & Terrazzo Company can help you. We have been operating for more than six decades, offering first-class hard-surface solutions for flooring, wall tiles, and kitchen countertops.

F & M Tile

Recent Inspiration

Copyright 2020, F & M Tile & Terrazzo Co., Inc. All right reserved